Compare Gold IRA Companies
Six well-known Gold IRA companies, side by side, using only what each company and the Better Business Bureau publish. Where a company doesn’t publish a number, we say so. Ask them for it in writing before you decide.
Last checked: November 14, 2026. Company facts read November 11, 2026. Sources are listed at the bottom.
Gold and silver prices today
−$121.58 (−3.15%) since the last daily close
Spot prices as of November 18, 2026, 1:35 PM ET. Source: xaus.com (indicative mid-market prices, not a quote to buy or sell). The price you pay a dealer is higher than spot, and the price a dealer pays you is lower. Prices change all the time and can go down as well as up.
How we’re paid: we may earn a commission if you request a kit or open an account through the links on this page. That doesn’t change the facts below, and we list every company the same way. The owner of this website may be paid to recommend American Bullion. The content of this website, including the positive review of American Bullion, the negative review of its competitors, and any other information may not be independent or neutral. This page is education, not financial, tax or legal advice. Precious metals can lose value, and past performance doesn’t guarantee future results.
At a glance
Read from each company’s website and bbb.org on November 11, 2026. “Not published” means we couldn’t find it on the company’s own site.
Swipe the table sideways to see all six companies.
| Goldco | Augusta Precious Metals | Noble Gold | Birch Gold Group | American Hartford Gold | American Bullion | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Minimum to open | Not published | Not published | Not published | Not published | Not published | $10,000 rollover recommended (to cover fees) |
| Published IRA fees | Not published | Not published | Not published (“lowest fees” claim, no figures) | Not published | First-year storage and custodian fees advertised as $0 (terms apply) | Through STRATA Trust: $25 setup + $160/yr (Precious Metals IRA); other plans $200–$275/yr |
| Custodian named | Not named on site | Not named on site | “Trusted custodian” (not named) | “IRS-approved custodians” (not named) | Not named on site | STRATA Trust Company |
| Storage named | Not named on site | Not named on site | Texas depository | Delaware Depository, Brink’s, IDS, Texas Precious Metals Depository | Delaware Depository | Delaware Depository |
| Metals | Gold, silver | Gold, silver | Gold, silver, platinum, palladium | Gold, silver, platinum, palladium | Gold, silver, platinum, palladium | Gold, silver, platinum (palladium in IRA pages) |
| Buy-back | Yes (“buy back program”) | Not described on homepage | Yes (“guaranteed buyback”) | Not described on homepage | “Buyback commitment” badge | “Buyback commitment” badge |
| BBB rating | A+ (accredited 2011) | A+ (accredited 2015) | A+ (accredited 2017) | A+ (accredited) | A+ (accredited 2016) | Not confirmed on bbb.org |
| BBB complaints, last 3 years | 73 | 1 | 3 | 9 | 116 | — |
Complaint counts alone don’t tell you much: bigger companies have more customers. Read how each complaint was answered on bbb.org.
Gold IRA cost calculator: what does the first year really cost?
Most of what a Gold IRA costs isn’t in the yearly fee. It’s in the price you pay for the metal (the dealer’s markup over the spot price) and the price the dealer pays you when you sell it back. Enter the numbers a company quotes you, and the calculator shows the total cost and how much the metal’s price has to rise just for you to break even. Our Gold IRA fees guide explains each fee.
- Metal you own, at spot value
- $47,619
- Paid in markup
- $2,381
- Fees over the years you hold
- $300
- Lost to the sell-back discount
- $952
- Total cost if the price doesn’t move
- $3,633 (7.3%)
The metal’s price must rise 7.8% before you break even.
These starting numbers are an example, not any company’s quote. Replace them with the figures a company gives you in writing.
How it works: the markup is the difference between what you pay and the metal’s spot value. The sell-back discount is how far below spot a dealer buys it back. Break-even is the price rise needed for the metal to be worth what you put in plus the fees, after the sell-back discount. Taxes, shipping and any minimum-balance fees aren’t included.
A worked example
Say you roll $50,000 into a Gold IRA. The dealer’s markup is 5%, so the coins you get are worth about $47,619 at spot. Setup costs $50 and custodian plus storage costs $250 a year. If you sold after one year at a buy-back price 2% under spot, you’d get about $46,667 back. With the $300 of fees, that’s about $3,633 less than you put in, or 7.3%, even though the price of gold didn’t move. Gold would have to rise about 7.8% just to get you back to even. Hold for five years and the fees grow to $1,300, so the break-even rise grows to about 9.9%.
How much the markup matters: $50,000 over 1, 5 and 10 years
Same example ($50 setup, $250 a year, sold back 2% under spot), with only the dealer’s markup changed. Each cell shows what you’d be down if the gold price didn’t move, and the price rise you’d need to break even.
| Dealer markup | After 1 year | After 5 years | After 10 years |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3% | $2,727 down; needs +5.7% | $3,727 down; needs +7.8% | $4,977 down; needs +10.5% |
| 5% | $3,633 down; needs +7.8% | $4,633 down; needs +9.9% | $5,883 down; needs +12.6% |
| 8% | $4,930 down; needs +10.9% | $5,930 down; needs +13.1% | $7,180 down; needs +15.8% |
These are examples, not quotes. None of the six companies here publishes its markup, so ask for it in writing on the exact coins you’d buy. Taxes, shipping and minimum-balance fees aren’t included.
The same arithmetic is why “premium,” proof and collectible coins deserve a hard look. Their markups are often far higher than standard bullion coins and bars, and that markup comes out of your balance on day one.
The companies, one by one
“Stands out for” comes straight from the table above: it’s the one fact where each company differs most from the others, not a rating.
Goldco
Stands out for: a published buy-back program
What we found
- Gold and silver IRAs, plus direct purchases
- Publishes a buy-back program
- BBB A+, accredited since 2011
Watch for
- No fees, minimum, custodian or depository on its site
- 73 BBB complaints in 3 years (a large company: read the answers)
Augusta Precious Metals
Stands out for: the fewest BBB complaints here (1 in 3 years)
What we found
- Gold and silver IRAs; in business since 2012 (per its website)
- BBB A+, accredited since 2015
- Free company-comparison checklist
Watch for
- No fees, minimum, custodian or depository on its site
- Buy-back not described on its homepage
Noble Gold
Stands out for: all four metals plus a guaranteed buy-back
What we found
- Gold, silver, platinum and palladium
- Guaranteed buy-back; Texas storage
- BBB A+, accredited since 2017, 3 complaints in 3 years
Watch for
- Says “lowest fees” but publishes no figures
- Custodian not named
Birch Gold Group
Stands out for: the most storage choices (four depositories named)
What we found
- Gold, silver, platinum and palladium
- Names four depositories on its site
- BBB A+, 9 complaints in 3 years
Watch for
- Fees, minimum and custodian not published
- Buy-back not described on its homepage
American Hartford Gold
Stands out for: a $0 first-year storage and custodian fee offer
What we found
- Gold, silver, platinum and palladium
- Advertises $0 first-year storage and custodian fees (read the terms)
- Delaware Depository; BBB A+, accredited since 2016
Watch for
- Fees from year two on not published
- 116 BBB complaints in 3 years, the most here
American Bullion
Stands out for: the only published fee schedule here
What we found
- Names its custodian (STRATA): $25 setup + $160 a year
- Delaware Depository storage
- Suggests a $10,000 minimum rollover
Watch for
- BBB rating not confirmed on bbb.org
- Markup over spot not published
Goldco
What it publishes: gold and silver IRAs and direct purchases, and a buy-back program. What it doesn’t: a fee schedule, a minimum, or the names of its custodian and depository. BBB: A+, accredited since 2011, 73 complaints in the last three years. Goldco is one of the larger companies in this group, which partly explains the higher complaint count, so read how the complaints were answered. Ask in writing: the total first-year cost and the markup on the exact coins it recommends.
Augusta Precious Metals
What it publishes: gold and silver IRAs, a start date of 2012, and a free company-comparison checklist. What it doesn’t: fees, a minimum, or its custodian and depository on the homepage. BBB: A+, accredited since 2015, 1 complaint in three years, the fewest in this group. Ask in writing: the minimum, the fees, and what it pays when you sell back.
Noble Gold
What it publishes: all four IRA metals, a guaranteed buy-back, and storage in Texas. What it doesn’t: fee figures (it says “lowest fees” without numbers) or the custodian’s name. BBB: A+, accredited since 2017, 3 complaints in three years. Ask in writing: the actual fees behind the “lowest fees” claim, and the buy-back price terms.
Birch Gold Group
What it publishes: all four IRA metals and the names of four depositories (Delaware Depository, Brink’s, IDS and Texas Precious Metals Depository), which gives you a storage choice. What it doesn’t: fees, a minimum, or which custodian it uses. BBB: A+, accredited, 9 complaints in three years. Ask in writing: the custodian’s name and whether storage is segregated or commingled.
American Hartford Gold
What it publishes: all four IRA metals, Delaware Depository storage, and an offer of $0 storage and custodian fees in the first year. What it doesn’t: the fees after year one or a minimum. BBB: A+, accredited since 2016, 116 complaints in three years, the most in this group. Ask in writing: what the fees are from year two on, and whether the free-fees offer depends on buying certain coins.
American Bullion
What it publishes: more than any other company here: its custodian (STRATA Trust Company), the fee schedule ($25 setup and $160 a year for the Precious Metals IRA, other plans $200 to $275 a year), Delaware Depository storage, and a suggested $10,000 minimum rollover. What we couldn’t confirm: a BBB rating on bbb.org. Ask in writing: the markup over spot, which the fee schedule doesn’t cover.
How a Gold IRA works
A Gold IRA is a self-directed individual retirement account that holds physical precious metals instead of, or alongside, stocks and funds. The tax rules are the same as any IRA: a traditional Gold IRA is tax-deferred, and a Roth Gold IRA can be tax-free in retirement if you meet the Roth rules. What’s different is who does the work.
- A custodian opens and runs the account. It must be a bank or an IRS-approved non-bank trustee. It handles the paperwork and reports to the IRS.
- A dealer (the companies on this page) sells you the metal. The dealer sets the markup over spot, which is usually the biggest cost.
- A depository stores the metal. Federal law says IRA bullion must be in the physical possession of the trustee, so you can’t keep it at home or in your own safe deposit box.
Money usually comes in from an existing account. A direct transfer, where your old IRA or 401(k) sends the money straight to the new custodian, is the cleanest way. You can also make yearly contributions: for 2026 the IRS limit is $7,500, or $8,600 if you’re 50 or older, and that limit is shared across all your IRAs.
Which metals an IRA can hold
Under section 408(m) of the tax code, most metals and coins count as “collectibles,” and buying a collectible inside an IRA is treated as taking money out. The exceptions are certain US-minted gold, silver and platinum coins, coins issued under a state’s laws, and gold, silver, platinum and palladium bullion at least as pure as the minimum fineness for metals delivered on regulated futures markets, as long as a trustee holds it. In practice, ask the dealer and the custodian to confirm in writing that each product they sell you is IRA-eligible.
Transfers and rollovers
There are two ways to move retirement money. In a direct transfer, the money goes from one custodian to the other and never touches your hands; the IRS doesn’t count it as a rollover. In an indirect rollover, the money is paid to you and you have 60 days to deposit it in the new IRA. The IRS allows only one IRA-to-IRA indirect rollover in any 12-month period, counting all your IRAs together, and it can’t waive that limit. Rollovers from a 401(k) or other workplace plan into an IRA don’t count toward it. If tax was withheld from a payment made to you, you have to make up the withheld amount from other money to roll over the full balance.
Taking money out
Withdrawals follow the normal IRA rules. From a traditional Gold IRA, most people must start required minimum distributions at age 73. You can take them in cash, which means selling some metal, or “in kind,” where the custodian ships you the coins and their value counts as the distribution. Either way, plan for it: you may have to sell metal at whatever the price is that year.
Gold IRA vs other ways to own gold
A Gold IRA isn’t the only way to hold gold. Here is how the main options differ on costs, taxes and how easy they are to sell. With every one of them, the price of gold can fall.
Swipe the table sideways to see all four options.
| Gold IRA | Gold ETF in a regular IRA | Coins or bars you keep yourself | Gold ETF in a taxable account | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| What you own | Physical metal, held by a depository for your IRA | Shares of a fund that holds gold | Physical metal in your hands | Shares of a fund that holds gold |
| Main costs | Dealer markup, plus yearly custodian and storage fees | The fund’s yearly expense ratio, plus any trading cost | Dealer markup, plus your own safe storage and insurance | The fund’s yearly expense ratio, plus any trading cost |
| Taxes | IRA rules: tax-deferred (traditional) or tax-free (Roth, if you qualify) | IRA rules, same as a Gold IRA | Gains taxed as collectibles, up to a 28% long-term rate | Physically backed gold funds are generally taxed as collectibles, up to 28% long-term |
| Selling | Through the custodian and a dealer; the dealer’s buy-back price applies | Any trading day, at the market price | To a dealer, at the dealer’s buy price | Any trading day, at the market price |
| Good to know | No home storage; rollovers and transfers have rules (see above) | No metal to hold or ship; you can’t take coins out | Theft and loss are your risk | No retirement-account tax shelter |
Tax treatment depends on your situation and can change; check with a tax professional. A fund’s costs and holdings are in its prospectus.
How to choose a Gold IRA company
- Get the total cost in writing. Setup, custodian, storage and the markup over spot on the exact coins you’d buy. Put the numbers into the calculator above.
- Prefer standard bullion. Widely traded coins and bars usually carry lower markups than “premium” or proof coins. Ask why if a company steers you toward the expensive ones.
- Know the custodian and depository by name. Ask whether your metal is stored segregated (your own coins, set apart) or commingled (pooled with others), and what the price difference is.
- Read the buy-back terms. A “buy-back program” is only useful if you know the price. Ask how far below spot they buy back.
- Check the BBB record yourself. Look at the rating, the number of complaints and, most of all, how they were answered.
- Watch for pressure. Urgent deadlines, scary forecasts and “free silver” offers are reasons to slow down. A free-metal promotion is often paid for in the price of the coins.
- Compare two or three quotes. Line them up side by side. A company that won’t put fees in writing is a red flag.
Five questions to ask any Gold IRA company, in writing
- What is the total first-year cost: setup, custodian, storage, and your markup over spot on the coins I’d buy?
- Which custodian and which depository will hold my metal? Segregated or commingled storage?
- What exactly will you pay if I sell back, and is that in writing?
- Are the coins you recommend standard bullion or “premium” coins, and why?
- What is the minimum, and what happens to fees if my balance falls below it?
Get the answers from two or three companies and compare them line by line.
Red flags: when to walk away
Federal regulators have warned for years about precious-metals and self-directed IRA fraud aimed at retirees. These are the warning signs they and the courts point to. One of them is reason enough to slow down; two or more, walk away.
- A cold call, text or social-media message you didn’t ask for. The CFTC lists unsolicited offers as a common scam tactic.
- Promises of “guaranteed profit” or “zero risk.” The SEC’s self-directed IRA alert calls words like these hallmarks of fraud. Metals can and do fall in price.
- A “home storage” or “checkbook” Gold IRA. In McNulty v. Commissioner (2021), the Tax Court treated IRA gold coins kept at home as taxable distributions. IRA metal must be held by the trustee.
- Pushing proof, “premium” or collectible coins. These usually carry much bigger markups than standard bullion, and some coins aren’t IRA-eligible at all.
- No total cost or buy-back price in writing. Regulators have seen markups above 300% in fraud cases. If a company won’t put its numbers on paper, don’t sign.
- “Your custodian approved it.” Custodians generally don’t check whether an investment is a good one. A real custodian doesn’t make a product legitimate.
- A deadline or a scare story. “Prices go up Friday,” “the banks are collapsing,” “free silver if you act today.” Good decisions can wait a week.
- Buying metal on credit or “leverage.” The CFTC says leveraged metal deals are generally illegal unless the seller is a registered exchange or delivers the metal within 28 days.
Before you send money, check any custodian against the IRS list of approved non-bank trustees, and report suspected fraud to the CFTC (cftc.gov/complaint) or your state securities regulator.
How we compared them
We picked six well-known Gold IRA companies whose affiliate programs we belong to. That’s also why the list isn’t longer: we only list companies we’ve read up on closely. We read each company’s own website and its Better Business Bureau profile, and we only list what those sources say. If a fact appears only on someone else’s review site, we leave it out. Where a company doesn’t publish something, the table says “Not published” rather than guessing.
We don’t give star ratings or rank the companies from best to worst, because the facts that matter most (the markup on your coins and the buy-back price) aren’t published by most of them. The way to find the best company for you is to ask for those numbers and compare them. We re-check the table regularly and update the “last checked” date at the top each time.
The “Stands out for” line on each company card is the one fact in our table where that company differs most from the others, such as the fewest complaints or the only published fee schedule. It describes, it doesn’t rank. The “Watch for” lines are what the company doesn’t publish or what its BBB record shows.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best Gold IRA company?
There isn’t one answer, because the biggest cost, the markup on the coins you buy, depends on the company and the product and most companies don’t publish it. Ask two or three companies for a written quote and put the numbers into the calculator on this page. The lowest total cost with clear buy-back terms is usually the better deal.
How much does a Gold IRA cost?
There are usually three parts: a setup fee, yearly custodian and storage fees, and the dealer’s markup over the spot price. The one company here that publishes its fees, American Bullion, lists $25 to set up and $160 a year for its Precious Metals IRA through STRATA Trust. The markup is separate and usually larger than the yearly fees.
What is the minimum to open a Gold IRA?
Most companies on this page don’t publish a minimum. American Bullion suggests a $10,000 rollover to cover fees. Ask each company directly, and ask what happens if your balance later falls below it.
Can I keep my Gold IRA metal at home?
No. The tax code says IRA bullion must be in the physical possession of the IRA’s trustee. Holding it yourself can be treated as taking it out of the IRA, with taxes and possible penalties.
What metals can go in a Gold IRA?
Certain US-minted gold, silver and platinum coins, coins issued under a state’s laws, and gold, silver, platinum and palladium bullion that meets a minimum purity, held by a trustee. Other coins and metals count as collectibles. Ask the custodian to confirm each product is IRA-eligible.
How much can I put into a Gold IRA in 2026?
The IRS limit for yearly IRA contributions in 2026 is $7,500, or $8,600 if you’re 50 or older, shared across all your IRAs. Transfers and rollovers of money already in retirement accounts don’t count toward that limit.
Can I roll my 401(k) into a Gold IRA?
Usually yes, once you’ve left that employer, and some plans allow it while you still work there. A direct transfer from the plan to the new custodian avoids the 60-day deadline and tax withholding. Check your plan’s rules first.
What is the one-rollover-per-year rule?
You can make only one indirect IRA-to-IRA rollover (where the money is paid to you first) in any 12-month period, counting all your IRAs. Direct trustee-to-trustee transfers and rollovers from a 401(k) aren’t limited this way.
What does “markup over spot” mean?
The spot price is the market price for raw metal. Dealers sell coins and bars above spot to cover their costs and profit. The difference is the markup. If you pay $1,050 for metal with a spot value of $1,000, the markup is 5%.
Do Gold IRA companies buy the metal back?
Several on this page advertise a buy-back program or commitment, but none publishes its buy-back prices. Ask how far below spot they pay and get it in writing before you buy.
About this page
This page is written and checked by the team at investingoldandsilverira.com. We’re an affiliate website, not a dealer, custodian or financial adviser, and we don’t hold anyone’s money or metal. Every fact here comes from the sources listed below, and the date at the top shows when we last checked them. If you spot something that’s out of date, tell us through our disclosures page.
Sources
Company websites: goldco.com, augustapreciousmetals.com, noblegoldinvestments.com, birchgold.com, americanhartfordgold.com, americanbullion.com. Ratings and complaint counts: bbb.org company profiles. All read November 11, 2026. Tax rules: IRS Publication 590-A (2026 contribution limits), the IRS page “Rollovers of retirement plan and IRA distributions”, IRS Announcement 2014-32 (one rollover per year), the IRS page “Investments in collectibles in individually directed qualified plan accounts”, and 26 U.S.C. section 408(m). Read November 14, 2026. Fraud warnings: CFTC customer advisory “10 Things to Ask Before Buying Physical Gold, Silver, or Other Metals” and its leveraged-metals guidance; SEC, NASAA and FINRA investor alert “Self-Directed IRAs and the Risk of Fraud” (updated 2023); McNulty v. Commissioner, 157 T.C. No. 10 (2021). Read November 14, 2026. Companies change their offers; check their current terms before you act.